5 signs your website is costing you customers (and how to fix it)

An outdated website rarely announces itself. It just sends fewer calls than it should. Here are five warning signs and practical fixes for each one.
Frustrated woman with her head in her hands in front of a laptop

Your website is often the first impression a potential customer gets of your business, and first impressions happen fast. Research consistently shows people form an opinion about a site within seconds. If your website isn’t pulling its weight, it might be quietly turning visitors away before they ever reach out. An outdated website rarely announces itself. It just sends fewer calls than it should.

Here are five signs it’s time for a refresh, and what to do about each one.

1. It’s not mobile-friendly

More than half of all web traffic now comes from phones. If your site is hard to navigate, has tiny text, or requires pinching and zooming on mobile, you’re losing much of your audience before they even see what you offer.

Smiling older man browsing on his smartphone at home

How to fix it:

  • Open your site on your own phone and try to do the one thing customers most often want, like calling you or finding your hours. If it takes more than a couple of taps, that’s the problem to solve.
  • Make text large enough to read without zooming, and buttons big enough to tap with a thumb.
  • Keep the menu short and put your phone number where it’s always one tap away.
  • If the site was built before phones were the norm and simply shrinks on a small screen, it usually needs to be rebuilt rather than patched.

2. It loads slowly

Every extra second a page takes to load increases the chance a visitor leaves. Google also uses page experience, including speed, as a ranking signal, so a slow site can hurt your search rankings too, compounding the problem.

How to fix it:

  • Run your homepage through Google’s free PageSpeed Insights tool and look at the mobile score first.
  • Resize and compress images. Oversized photos straight from a camera or phone are the most common cause of a slow site.
  • Remove plugins, widgets, and tracking scripts you no longer use.
  • Look at your hosting. Bargain hosting shared with thousands of other sites can slow down even a well-built website.

3. It looks dated

Design trends shift, and a site that looked sharp five years ago can now feel stale or untrustworthy. Visitors often equate outdated design with an outdated, or even closed, business.

How to fix it:

  • Replace generic stock photos with real photos of your team, your work, and your location. Nothing builds trust faster.
  • Remove anything that dates the site: old events, expired specials, a years-old copyright year, or a “news” section that stopped in 2019.
  • Show recent reviews and testimonials, so visitors can see you’re active and trusted today.
  • Refresh fonts, colors, and spacing for a cleaner look. Often that’s enough without starting over.

4. There’s no clear call to action

If someone lands on your homepage and isn’t sure what to do next, whether that’s calling you, booking a service, or filling out a form, you’re leaving customers on the table.

Woman on her couch calling a business on her phone

How to fix it:

  • Decide the single most important action for each page, and make it the most visible button.
  • Use clear, specific button text like “Get a free quote” or “Book an appointment” instead of “Submit” or “Learn more.”
  • Put your phone number in the header of every page, and repeat the call to action at the bottom of long pages.
  • Shorten your contact form. Name, phone or email, and a message is usually all you need to start the conversation.

5. It’s not built to grow with you

A site built on outdated technology or a rigid template can turn simple updates, like new services, new pricing, or new locations, into a hassle instead of a quick edit. And when updates are a hassle, they stop happening, which makes every other problem on this list worse.

How to fix it:

  • Make sure you or your staff can update hours, photos, and text yourselves, without calling a developer.
  • Check that your site runs on software that’s still supported and regularly updated. Unsupported software is a security risk.
  • Confirm that you own your website and domain name. If you ever change web companies, you should be able to take them with you.

Is your outdated website actually costing you? Check the numbers

You don’t have to guess. If you have Google Analytics or a similar tool on your site, look for these warning signs:

  • Phone visitors leave much faster than desktop visitors. That usually points to a mobile problem.
  • Plenty of visits, but few calls or form submissions. People are finding you and not taking the next step.
  • Many visitors leave from the homepage without clicking anything. The first impression isn’t landing.

No analytics? Start asking new customers how they found you and whether they looked at your website first. Their answers are often the most honest feedback you’ll get.

Refresh or rebuild?
Some of these problems can be fixed in an afternoon. Others mean the site needs to be rebuilt. Our guide, Should you fix your website or start over?, walks through how to tell the difference, and how to protect your Google rankings either way.

How we help

We look at your site first and tell you honestly whether it needs a few fixes or a fresh start. When it’s time for something new, our web design work starts with what your site needs to do: tell people what you do, show them you’re the real deal, and make it easy to contact you. Our hosting and care plans keep it fast, secure, and up to date after launch. We work with businesses across mid-Michigan, and you’ll get a fixed quote before any work starts. Curious what that might cost? See what a small business website costs.

Wondering whether your website is costing you customers? Get a free quote and we’ll take a look.

The FWS team

Auburn, Michigan. FWS is a web studio that designs, builds, and hosts websites for local businesses, national brands, and international clients. Questions about your own site? Ask us.

On this page

Have a question?

Get a straight answer about your site — no pressure.

Free website planner

A 7-page checklist and planner for your next website. Print it or fill it in on a tablet.

Keep reading

More straight answers.

Frustrated man on the phone while looking at his laptop

Why isn’t my business showing up on Google? 9 common reasons

You search for your business and you’re nowhere. The cause is usually one of a handful of fixable problems. Here’s how to find yours.

Read article ›

Calculator and monthly budget charts on a desk

How much should a small business spend on Google Ads?

Google Ads has no minimum spend, and Google won’t tell you a number. Here’s a simple way to work out a Google Ads budget that makes sense for your business.

Read article ›

Two people handing over a set of keys in an office

Do you actually own your website? How to check, and why it matters

Most business owners assume they own their website. Many find out otherwise at the worst possible moment. Here’s how to check what you own, and what to do if you don’t.

Read article ›

Web design & development

Custom sites that make it easy to call you

A good website does three jobs: tells people what you do, shows you’re the real deal, and makes it easy to reach you. We design around those first — then build it fast, in-house.

Example web dashboard illustration

Hosting & care plans

Hosting that stays up, with a person to call

Your website needs a home and someone keeping an eye on it. Our care plans cover both, so you’re never the one who finds out your site is down.

Example host dashboard illustration

Local SEO

Show up when people nearby search

When someone nearby searches for what you do, Google shows a map with three businesses. Local SEO is the work of getting you into those spots — and we show you the progress on a map every month.

Example seo dashboard illustration

Google Ads & Business Profile

Be at the top of Google today

SEO takes time. Google Ads puts you at the top of the results now, and you only pay when someone clicks — with every call and form tracked so you know what each lead cost.

Example ads dashboard illustration

ADA compliance & PDF remediation

Documents everyone can read

Townships, schools, and many businesses need their PDFs to work for people using screen readers. We handle remediation through our partner ADAComply — and if we host your site, finished documents post automatically.

Example ada dashboard illustration

Graphic design & branding

One look everywhere your name appears

When your website, your truck, your business card, and your social pages all look like they belong together, people remember you. If it has your name on it, we can design it.

Example brand dashboard illustration

Services

Areas we serve